Saturday 7 June 2014

Scaphoid ligament reconstruction surgery - Brunelli procedure

I was writing this in my diary (well actually using the voice text on my phone as I can't write and left handed typing which takes ages!!) and until I started writing didn't realise how fed up I'm actually feeling about my wrist. I've decided to share my journey (if you can call it that) and feelings on my blog. (Which I actually haven't written on in years so writing about this and keeping people up to date will encourage me to start writing on my blog again (well that's my aim!!!)).

It has just been over six months (Thursday 21st November 2013) since I actually hurt my wrist. I never imagined that me trapping my wrist in the car boot would cause this many problems and still be going on now!!

So how did I do it and what problems and treatment have I received so far?

Back in November I drove some children from my daughters school to an archery activity at the local secondary school. In between dropping them off and picking them up, I went and picked up a Christmas present for my daughter. I didn't want her seeing the box so I tried putting it in the boot of the car - but everytime I tried to close the boot the box keep failing out (Ford Galaxy - little boot when all seats are up), so in a mad genius moment I thought I could hold the box in place and slam the boot shut at the same time, of course the plan was to remove my hand in time before the boot shut. I have to say I have done this before and when I do tell some people they do say they have done it too - thinking when your going camping and all your camping things don't quite fit in, how many times have we held them in place and shut the door, easily removing your arm/hand in time OR am I just trying to justify what I did!!!!! I think the difference is when I did it this time, I didn't take into account that the car we have now is a Ford Galaxy and the car boot door is twice the size and heavy as our last car - so the distance in removing my arm was a little bit longer than our old car. OK YES I AM TRYING TO JUSTIFY THAT I HAD A MOMENT OF MADNESS - A STUPID IDEA AND NOW I AM PAYING THE PRICE FOR IT.

I didn't go to hospital that day as I really just didn't see how I would have time but yes it did hurt like hell and yes I did have to sit at the side of the road with tears rolling down my cheeks while I tried to think of what I was going to do - I still had five children to pick up and a swimming lesson to go to. So I gritted my teeth and carried on. But by the next day my wrist was so swollen that Paul took me to the hospital, they x-rayed it and said there was no break and that I just needed to rest it. A week later I was in agony and the swelling was worse, I went back to hospital - they re x-rayed it and still found nothing but because of the swelling they decided that I should see a specialist, which was a few days later.

I never expected the problems that have resulted in this accident, I actually thought that I had broken my wrist and how I wish I had because it would have healed by now. Whenever I'm at hospital that's all I ever hear, 'if only you had broken a bone, you would have been healed by now, ligaments are so much worst' - well yes thanks for telling me, I know that now!!!! I saw an orthopaedic consultant who straightaway had me in a cast and booked me two days later for an MRI - she was concerned that I had partially teared my scaphoid ligament in my wrist. The results from the MRI was inconclusive but she was still concerned and wanted me to see a orthopaedic hand surgeon. Throughout this time I was in a cast for a few weeks then put in a splint. I couldn't drive and found it really difficult to do things like write and make cakes!! I was in loads of pain and the swelling was still there. I went to see the hand surgeon the second week in January. He looked at my MRI and moved my wrist around - his conclusion was that he really didn't think I had torn my ligament. He booked me into phsyio and said he thought that would help and fix the problem but would also book me into having an wrist arthroscopy surgery in case phsyio wasn't working - if my wrist was feeling better then I was to cancel the appointment. So I had six weeks before surgery to get fixed - well after six weeks (actually eight as surgery was cancelled night before and rebooked two weeks later) of wearing a splint and lots of phsyio there was no difference - I was in loads of pain, the best way I can explain it is - it felt like someone was stamping on my wrist ALL the time and then if I moved it, it felt like someone was trying to chop my hand off!! I know someone said they thought I was making it up - if only!!!! I didn't even think for a moment when I first injured my wrist that the pain would be so bad. It would bring tears to my eyes on many occasions and since injuring it I haven't slept a full night - I just can't sleep, I'm in pain and can't get comfortable.

So now the plan was this wrist arthroscopy key hole surgery where a camera was going to be inserted into my wrist in three areas to see where (if one) the partially tare in my scaphoid ligament was and if one was found then my surgeon Mr Field would repair it at the same time. I expected to wake up from surgery fixed (well after recover!) but I woke up to be told by Mr Field that he couldn't fix it without talking to me first as it wasn't a partial tare but a full scaphoid tare - when catching my wrist in the car boot I had ripped my ligament straight off my two wrist bones!!

So why is this ligament important in my wrist? The ligament between the two bones in the wrist (scaphoid and the lunate) should normally move together as they are joined by a ligament. When the ligament is damaged they don't, this causing pain and early onset arthritis.

Two weeks later I was told the next plan - I would be having a surgery called the Brunelli procedure were an incision is made over the back of the wrist and the two bones identified. Three small incisions are made on the front of the wrist and lower arm and through one they take half of the tendon used to reconstitute the ligament, which is then passed through a drill-hole made through the scaphoid bone. The ligament is then taken up through the scaphoid bone and fixed onto the lunate bone to try and reconstitute the ligament. The two bones are wired in place. These wires are left in for eight weeks after which time they will then need to be removed by surgery. Without the surgery I would loss about 30-40% range in my movement and be in pain most of the time. With the surgery hopefully the restriction of movement will decrease to 20-30% and the operation is very successful in helping the pain in 80% of cases. Complications from the surgery are - a chance of fracturing the scaphoid while drilling through it. A chance of infection. PAIN!! The operation is painful and will take twelve months to recover from and the original pain prior to surgery can persist. Potential damage to the blood supply to the scaphoid with avascular necrosis, this is a complication that could occur and could result in your wrist becoming stiffer and more painful.

So I had a lot to think about before saying yes to surgery but decided that the surgery was my be option.

Six weeks later I had this surgery - I'm just over five weeks post surgery now and have so many mixed emotions about the surgery/the pain after(!)/and the future!

The pain from surgery has been so bad - it hurts all the time and with the bad reaction I had from the medication, it has been horrible. I have just had enough, I just want A GOOD NIGHTS SLEEP!!!!! The surgery itself went well but like I said the pain...........not only is there the pain from surgery, there's the pain that was there before (the all the time pain) but also I have pain often from moving one of my fingers resulting in shooting/cramping style pain in my wrist lasting for what seems like eternity. Then there has been the pain from the casts - I've had four in four weeks (finally having one that is comfortable) the first was ok until the swelling started going down then it became too big and started rubbing, the second was cracking so they wanted to change it and the third was on so tight I had continual pins and needles in my arm. Like I said finally the fourth one is ok. I do hate having a cast - my thumb is immobilised in the cast which drives me mad!

One of my friends asked what I'm looking forward to the most once my cast is off, my reply straight away was putting my hand in the bath - but within five minutes I think I changed my mind about 100 times.....buttering my own toast, shaving under my left arm without asking Paul to do it(!), opening a bottle of Pepsi max, driving (well that's still months away), writing with a pen, writing on my book blog, using a pair of scissors, ironing (yes I know - sad!!)...............

Will it be worth it? I have read lots thought and comments from people who have had this operation, and it's been really mixed reviews - some say it's been a success even though they still have some restriction in movement and some pain but less than before the operation. Others have said it's the worst decision they made, with worst or no range of movement and extreme pain for years later. I guess at the moment I have no way in knowing which way my results will be, I hope they will be for the better. I know my wrist will never be the same - I have been told that on many occasions and I think it's this that gets me down. I do try to be positive but I do think I'm allowed some down days. I am just so grateful for Paul who has been such a great help, and for my family and friends who have given me moral support - especially my one friend Frances who has listened and supported me throughout this whole thing. And I'm lucky to have a great job looking after a little boy whose parents (and friends) have been very supportive and allowed me to have time off whenever needed.

I would love to say this is the end of it, but as I have previously said I'm still in a cast. My next operation is 25th of June - I will be put to sleep again to be opened up to see if the ligament has taken and healed. If it has the pins well be removed and I will be in a bandage for around four weeks, then physio will start - 12 to 18 months!!!!!

Honestly what an idiot was I trapping my own wrist in the car boot.....yes a complete idiot I hear you say!! I will keep you up to date and let you know my progress.


- Posted using BlogPress

15 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Rebecca,

    Many thanks for your info re the Brunelli procedure. Just wandered how you are getting on now and if overall you thought it was worth the operation?

    I have a Brunelli booked in for the 24th July, but have very little pain just a loose wrist. (The odd pain when I stretch in certain directions), so I am not sure my symptoms really need a Brunelli.

    My Scaphoid Lunate Ligament was torn completely when lifting one of my son over a style with a Dalmatian going the other way ;)

    As I have little pain I am very unsure if I should go for the op or not, but have been warned that it may get worse over the years and possibly cause arthritis.

    It would be great to hear how you got on, now you are a year or so down the road.

    Cheers,
    Rob

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Rob,
      I am nearly in the sam situation like you are / have been.
      My wrist is not really painful - just annoying pressure which I can release for some minutes by making a certain movement by holding my wrist with the other hand, then stretching it by bending it forward - "clack".
      Today I have visited (another) hospital for wrist injuries (what an Odyssey),
      there the large gap between scaphoid and Lunatum was visible.
      I have beend advised to do the Brunelli surgery, I do not have set a date for that - I am still unsure to do it or not - I can deal with the annoying feeling, but I fear the maybe (or surely?) arising arthrosis.
      In Germany we have a saying for this situation: deal with the devil or with the Belzebub?
      Ist your surgery now done? How did it went?

      All the best for you,
      Axel

      Delete
  4. Hello Rebecca,

    I am facing the same surgery - after all I have read I seem to be trapped.
    How are you doing today? Do you feel any improvements right now and do you still
    have to visit doctors, physio etc.?

    Thanks and all the best for you,
    Axel

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi all ,I have had the same procedure and 12 months down the line i have acute arthritis in it ,I had been mis diagnosed from the beginning after lifting my brother in law up (drunk ,dont ask!!) and tearing my ligaments in my wrist ,I had left it for 3 weeks hoping it would get better but never did . I was told by the fracture clinic i had a hairline fracture so i was put in a cast for 4 weeks ,After this i was scanned again then told my ligaments had torn away so referred to Wrightington hospital in Wigan were i was told by the specialist that due to being mis diagnosed i had to have reconstructive surgery and this would be the Brunelli procedure .I was informed i was already showing signs of acute arthritis and they told me in the future if the arthritis gets any worse then i might be better getting the wrist fused .
    I had the procedure last year and i feel it has made my wrist stronger but i have lost about 75% of the backwards movement and about 40% forward ,I do feel the procedure was needed but the pain from the arthritis is constant .I hope your procedures are successful and i wish you well for the future .

    John Foley

    ReplyDelete
  6. I had the brunelli procedure done 18 months ago.... although mt wrist is fixed and i dont have half as much pain as i did before the surgery ( i was left 2 1/2 years before diagnosis) im now left unable to bend my wrist and i do still get swelling and pain and my little finger was damaged in surgery so my little finger hurts and goes numb too.... I suppose i should be happy that my wrist is fixed.
    After reading your story one thing i am grateful for was that no wires were used during my surgery... the tendon was threaded through the bones and stitched and i had a cast on for 8 weeks.... so no need for more surgery and im also glad i wasnt put to sleep and could watch what was happening.
    Good luck with everyone else having this done.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I had the procedure around 5 months ago. It's a slow recovery process but it's slowly getting better. In the last week or so I have been getting an iced cold feeling in my wrist. Anyone else had this?

    ReplyDelete
  8. I'm so sorry everyone especially those who commented a long time ago!!! I haven't written anything on a blog for ages. My new year aim was to start up writing on my blogs again - so just coming on here now and seeing the comments. Didn't realise I hadn't set up emails to know when people comment. I feel bad for those who asked for advice and I didn't give any - sorry!!! I will do an update later tonight and let you know all that's happened since having my operation. It's been a long road and I'm still on it!!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. how are you right now? what are the things you can do and can't do? thanks

      Delete
  9. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I've added a video to beginning of blog about my experience with Scaphoid ligament reconstruction surgery - Brunelli procedure. Have a look

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. hello rebecca the video is not playing...thanks

      Delete
    2. Well that's because I put the video private not public!!! Never done a video on YouTube before so it took me ages and I still didn't do it right! I've changed it now. Thanks

      Delete
  11. Hi Folks,

    I had this procedure December 2015 and while the surgery was successful to relieve the moving wrist bones and subsequent pain it's not without trade offs. I had a piece of tendon transplanted, woven through the bones, attached with a single screw and immobilized by two rods and a cast for 6 weeks. The most painful experience of my life.

    I have a residual problem of very stiff fingers and reduced mobility. I'm probably
    50-60% of the mobility of my good wrist but no real pain and the strength is actually quite good.

    However, I can play golf and hockey without pain. It took a long time to build up enough mobility for golf but 14 months later I would say I am 90% (I play competitively as an amateur). I just started doing push-ups with my hand flat on the ground but that is still sensitive.

    I believe it will continue to get better and it needed to be done. The alternative was early arthritis followed by a total wrist fusion so is there really any choice? While surgeons operate all the time not many do this procedure very often. Apparently it's quite rare. My surgeon reminded me numerous times post-op that this in fact "major" surgery from a wrist repair perspective.

    If I had any advice it would be to find a surgeon who has done it numerous times and if you have to have rods for stability while in a cast that you have them leave the cast open where the rods protrude through the skin....my cast cover d the rods and was a constant source of discomfort.

    Thanks,
    Tony

    ReplyDelete